Cottage Corner

Fulham Football Club

Why bring on Davies and start all out defence when Trotta is on the bench

Views: 468

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Exactly.

Why swap a striker for a midfielder and then defend. The whole game changed for us when Pogrebnyak came off.

Do you really think throwing Trotta on today would be good for him or us? It would've been similar to bringing Ruiz on against Blackburn.

This is a prime example of why we need a few target men. If you play with one up front the player needs to hold it up. Sa could've done a job today. Has Trotta ever played the lone front man, is he a target man?

101 said:

Exactly.

Why swap a striker for a midfielder and then defend. The whole game changed for us when Pogrebnyak came off.

Not sure if he's ever played as a lone striker.

He would have been better than having midfielders up front though. We need more than one striker who can hold the ball up.

John Smith said:

This is a prime example of why we need a few target men. If you play with one up front the player needs to hold it up. Sa could've done a job today. Has Trotta ever played the lone front man, is he a target man?

101 said:

Exactly.

Why swap a striker for a midfielder and then defend. The whole game changed for us when Pogrebnyak came off.

Yes we really do. Hopefully Sa will be back soon, he has done a half decent job when in the mood. I think Dempsey is a bit underrated at holding the ball up though, if you lump it on to his head he'll lose it but play it to feet and he's strong enough to keep it and will probably win a free kick.

101 said:

Not sure if he's ever played as a lone striker.

He would have been better than having midfielders up front though. We need more than one striker who can hold the ball up.

John Smith said:

This is a prime example of why we need a few target men. If you play with one up front the player needs to hold it up. Sa could've done a job today. Has Trotta ever played the lone front man, is he a target man?

101 said:

Exactly.

Why swap a striker for a midfielder and then defend. The whole game changed for us when Pogrebnyak came off.

Another baffling move. Would have been a perfect time to give Trotta a chance being up 2 with 30 minutes left. But Jol returned to playing defense again and it nearly cost us. He obviously has no faith in him, so Trotta must really be screwing up in training. Maybe he took a penalty without permission in practice, so he'll never see the field again.

101 said:

Exactly.

Why swap a striker for a midfielder and then defend. The whole game changed for us when Pogrebnyak came off.

I think Jol got that one right. It would've been a real baptism of fire throwing Trotta on against Shawcross and Wilkinson.

Joe Molino said:

Another baffling move. Would have been a perfect time to give Trotta a chance being up 2 with 30 minutes left. But Jol returned to playing defense again and it nearly cost us. He obviously has no faith in him, so Trotta must really be screwing up in training. Maybe he took a penalty without permission in practice, so he'll never see the field again.

101 said:

Exactly.

Why swap a striker for a midfielder and then defend. The whole game changed for us when Pogrebnyak came off.

Agreed, Jol often tells us the youngsters aren't pushing the established players hard enough for places but refuses to let them have much of a go. Baffled!

We should give Trotta a chance but I dont think it was the sort of game or scernario to have taken a gamble on him. Davies is very experienced and always does a good job when on.

We needed to be three up for trotta. I thought the change was unfortunate but worked Ok. The thing is Pog is a real forward making good runs and angles. Clint is not that and plays much better from deeper.

Lewis Johnston said:

We should give Trotta a chance but I dont think it was the sort of game or scernario to have taken a gamble on him. Davies is very experienced and always does a good job when on.

2-0 up and a straight swap. When will we be in a better position to give the guy a run.

 

 

As said in previous posts we had a good shape until Pogs went off. As soon as that happened i would of pulled Ruiz. We needed someone who would hold the ball and at lease challenge for a couple of headers. IM starting to feel like Ruiz is not offering enough to the team to warrant a place in it. Would of left Murphy on and swapped Ruiz for Dixon and moved Dembele out wide. Sorry to bang on about Ruiz but he is far to light weight. When he has the ball there is no conviction. When he doesnt have it he rarely closes down and cannot win a tackle! With him on the pitch i feel we are down to 10 men for the majority of the game. 

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Latest Activity

OSTRICH WATCH (THE) replied to Logicalman's discussion 'Tipping League: Final Positions 2011-12'
"He's an idiot. You sound like one, too. "
46 seconds ago
Alex B posted a discussion

Barry out of Euros

Seems strange that Jagielka is the replacement. Surely, if Henderson is on standby, a like-for-like swap would make more sense?See More
8 minutes ago
ORGANIC WHITE replied to OSTRICH WATCH (THE)'s discussion 'When the Americans have gone, I vote we pick on people from Kent and Sussex'
"I reckon it's another of Tizzard's.  But there's so many of them it's hard to tell sometimes. "
12 minutes ago
dikranovich replied to EtuhuForNigeria's discussion 'Yanks... Please sign this bill of commitment to the club no matter what happens to Dempsey.'
"if michael bradley comes to fulham, he is not eventually replacing anybody.  it would be with immediate effect.  please dont let alex mcleish do your thinking for you.  "
17 minutes ago
ORGANIC WHITE replied to EtuhuForNigeria's discussion 'Why does everyone get confused between talent and technical ability?'
"Is keepy-uppy a talent or a technical ability?  I'm not sure but if forced I'd say technical ability.  However I wouldn't want the world record keepy-uppy player on my team.  No I wouldn't. Is landing a long pass…"
17 minutes ago
WhiteJC replied to WhiteJC's discussion 'Monday Fulham Stuff (28/05/12)...'
"...additional stories...   http://bit.ly/L6QH8d http://bit.ly/Ky8KFk ;"
17 minutes ago
Skidrow replied to Logicalman's discussion 'Tipping League: Final Positions 2011-12'
"Could my points total for week 38 be included? I'm listed for a 0 and look back at week 38. I played and scored."
20 minutes ago
Terrance Booker replied to OSTRICH WATCH (THE)'s discussion 'When the Americans have gone, I vote we pick on people from Kent and Sussex'
"Is OSTRICH WATCH (THE) a puppet of the original OSTRICH WATCH or is it someone completely different?"
20 minutes ago

© 2012   Created by Fulham FC.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service